Dodo Birds, a Golden Thread, and Empirically Supported Therapy
نویسندگان
چکیده
The revised edition of Jerome Frank's (1975) seminal text Persuasion and Healing: A Complete Study of Psychotherapy that I own is badly worn. It is yellowed, the pages are dog-eared, and the binding has long been broken, so much so that I keep the book in a plastic bag so that I will not lose any of the pages. I have purchased updated editions over the years; indeed I own a copy of the updated edition (Frank & Frank, 1991) that he revised with his daughter. But I preserve this original book because it opened me up to the notion of healing as an art as well as a science. A professor of mine, a rigidly trained psychoanalyst, made the book required reading because, as he said, it showed him that it was OK to speak to behaviorists.
منابع مشابه
Surgical treatment of bumblefoot in a captive golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos)
The golden eagle is one of the world's largest living birds. Footpad dermatitis, also known as plantar pododermatitis or bumblefoot, is a condition characterized by lesions due to contact with unhealthy "perching" conditions, such as plastic perches, sharp-cornered perches on the ventral footpad of birds. A young female golden eagle (Aquila chrysaetos) in Fars province of Iran was presented to ...
متن کاملAssembling the dodo in early modern natural history.
This paper explores the assimilation of the flightless dodo into early modern natural history. The dodo was first described by Dutch sailors landing on Mauritius in 1598, and became extinct in the 1680s or 1690s. Despite this brief period of encounter, the bird was a popular subject in natural-history works and a range of other genres. The dodo will be used here as a counterexample to the histo...
متن کاملThe Legacy of Saul Rosenzweig: The Profundity of the Dodo Bird
This article provides commentary on Saul Rosenzweig’s classic 1936 paper, “Some Implicit Common Factors in Diverse Methods of Psychotherapy,” with particular emphasis on his clever and prophetic invocation of the dodo bird verdict from Alice in Wonderland. The impact of this seminal contribution is discussed by a comparison of Rosenzweig’s original common factors proposal with modern formulatio...
متن کاملThe Dodo-bird Debate, Empirically Supported Relationships and Functional Analytic Psychotherapy
The dodo-bird verdict has haunted the literature on psychotherapy outcome since its early beginnings. It is based on the counter-intuitive finding that often highly diverging treatments do not differ much in effectiveness. There is evidence that much of the common effect of different treatments can be related to unspecific factors as opposed to treatment-specific techniques. The present paper o...
متن کاملEmpirically Supported Treatments in Psychotherapy: Towards an Evidence-Based or Evidence-Biased Psychology in Clinical Settings?
THE FIELD OF RESEARCH AND PRACTICE IN PSYCHOTHERAPY HAS BEEN DEEPLY INFLUENCED BY TWO DIFFERENT APPROACHES: the empirically supported treatments (ESTs) movement, linked with the evidence-based medicine (EBM) perspective and the "Common Factors" approach, typically connected with the "Dodo Bird Verdict". About the first perspective, since 1998 a list of ESTs has been established in mental health...
متن کامل